Eve Egoyan Plays Ann Southam’s SIMPLE LINES OF ENQUIRY reviewed by Stanley Fefferman
Monday, June 1st, 2009
Saturday, May 30, 2009. Enwave Theatre, Toronto
Being in the concert hall while Eve Egoyan plays the 12 movements of Ann Southam’s Simple Lines of Enquiry for solo piano is like being in an art gallery where 12 abstract canvases hang on white walls. The 12 movements of Simple Lines ‘depict’ slight-to-subtle variations of seemingly similar musical lines, hues and tonal materials. And, just as the experience of visual art occurs in a silent gallery, so the experience of this musical event, these sound paintings generate an atmosphere of silence.
Southam’s composition is atonal, minimalist, serial. Typically, you hear Ms. Egoyan play a cluster of 5-10 notes which are allowed to hang in the air, mingle their overtones, and fade away into near silence before she resumes her attack on the next cluster. These tone rows vibrating from the box of the fabulous Fazioli piano are like beads of different sizes, threaded at varying intervals along a continuity of overtones that seems to emerge as a principle subject of the music—a simple line of enquiry.
The melodies, such as they are, involve much repetition, like a lullaby. The end effect is to focus the mind and relax it at the same time, creating a steady state that binds the attack and flux of each note and each cluster together as a thing itself. This results in a kind of melting of the affections, as if Ms. Egoyan’s concentrated discipline develops a musical posture that enables a sense of fluidity to flow towards relaxation and the possibility of bliss.
The initial movements of Southam’s composition takes place more in the middle toward the high end of the keyboard. The later movements move the energy toward the deep end and facilitate that melting. As the piece progresses, there seems to emerge out the monochromatic subtleties of the tone rows, hints of romanticism. Out of the abstract purity of the music, nuances of narrative, passionate and dramatic arise as fleetingly glimpses, then subside into the coolness of abstraction.
As the in title Ms.Southam gave her work, this was the performance of an ‘Enquiry’, rather than a statement of anything. Her openness, and Ms. Egoyan’s daring presentation of the simple black and white of the music, remain appealing and memorable in my mind.
For more information about the Centrediscs recording of Ms. Egoyan’s performance of SIMPLE LINES OF ENQUIRY, please goto
www.centrediscs.ca
May 26, 2009, Factory Studio Theatre, Toronto.
Erica Goodman is one of the dedicatees of Chris Paul Harman’s Gott Lebet Noch (2008) concerto for harp and orchestra. Harman’s composition is based on a Bach chorale of the same name (eng: God Still Lives). Of his treatment of Bach, Harman says he has done some “reharmonization, fragmentation, chromatic melody alteration, retrogrades of individual phrases, layering of canons, registral displacement and extreme changes in tempi….” Because Harman did not write in extended techniques for the harp, we heard its natural timbral qualities and a sense of Bach mingle with the rarified orchestral dissonances, discords, percussive sonic booms, clangs, jangles, moaning winds and keening strings. The idea occurred that the modern title could be God Still Lives (or Not). Ms. Goodman’s extreme exertions were warmly applauded, and the piece’s other dedicatees, Alex Pauk and the Esprit Orchestra offered a bonus performance of “Brazil”, a 1944 Academy Award nominated tune by Ary Barroso that was a lot of fun.

Maestro Spivakov’s style of conducting is elegant and flowing as he demonstrates from the podium a full range of emotions. The orchestra follows like a ship before the wind. The string sound has a lustrous beauty; interjections of the winds and horns are perfectly clear; the low-register basses and brass add rich photographic blacks to the musical picture. The program of overly familiar compositions turns out to be full of springlike excitement and fresh insights.